Illegal Immigration This is a hotly contested issue in California, and there will inevitably be many points of view. One problem with any study of this nature, is the fact that all figures are based on estimations, and are not objectively experimental. Moreover, it is possible that the data is biased against undocumented aliens, as most research is done by the US government and other agencies wishing to draw attention to a potential problem that affects all US citizens. Because illegal immigration is widespread, and burdens a whole variety of social services, I believe it is best to break down services into smaller, more manageable fragments and examine them on an individual basis, compare and then see how this correlates with the big picture. For example, when looking at public school enrollment, (table 4.9) I believe it is more useful to look at a breakdown of exactly which counties have the greatest impacted schools and how undocumented aliens are affecting class sizes, costs to schools etc. Then compare data from other counties. I am rather confused by figures such as discussed in question 1 -- the Urban Institute estimates costs of illegal immigrants at $1.8 billion, whereas Calif's own initial estimate was $2.8 billion, which was later revised. How do we know which numbers to believe? Here, the discrepancy is $1 billion, not exactly something to disregard. Because of the complexity and sheer amounts of data to look at, I'm not sure this article is entirely appropriate to teach from, and I would predict some difficulty in comprehension of the data presented.